Calcaneus Fracture Surgery

Calcaneus fracture surgery: Dr Alexey Borshch, orthopaedic surgeon, gowned and masked in the operating theatre

What is calcaneus fracture surgery?

The calcaneus (heel bone) is the large bone at the back of the foot that takes your weight when you stand and walk. On its upper surface it forms the subtalar joint with the talus (the bone just below the ankle joint), which lets the foot tilt inwards and outwards on uneven ground. Calcaneus fractures make up to 2% of all fractures. They are mostly caused by a fall from a height and are common in younger adults (PMID 37933733). In England, hospital admissions for a calcaneus fracture occurred in 10.5 in every 100,000 men and 3.8 in every 100,000 women each year (PMID 30700122), and in Finland men were affected about three times as often as women (PMID 29202996).

A thorough clinical examination by a specialist and modern imaging help confirm the diagnosis. X-rays and CT scans show whether the fracture extends into the subtalar joint (an intra-articular fracture) and how far the pieces have moved apart (displacement). Many calcaneus fractures are treated without an operation; in Finland, 22% of people admitted to hospital with this fracture in 2012 had surgery (PMID 29202996).

Surgery is considered for some displaced fractures. The aim is to restore the height, length and width of the heel bone and the smooth surface of the subtalar joint, and to hold the pieces in place with plates and screws while the bone heals (open reduction and internal fixation). This can be done through a longer L-shaped incision on the outer side of the heel (extensile lateral approach), or with minimally invasive techniques: a smaller incision on the outer side of the foot just below the ankle (sinus tarsi approach), or screws placed through small incisions in the skin (percutaneous fixation) (PMID 30249288; PMID 30233817). In England, the share of calcaneus fracture operations done with closed, less invasive techniques rather than open surgery rose from 7.7% to 13.29% after 2015 (PMID 30700122).

What are the benefits of calcaneus fracture surgery?

Surgery can improve foot function and reduce long-term pain. In a Cochrane review of 12 randomised and quasi-randomised trials with 1,097 participants, surgery improved foot function scores 6 to 24 months after injury, lowered the risk of chronic pain by 44% and improved physical quality of life compared with treatment without surgery (PMID 37933733).

Restoring the shape of the joint may protect it in the long term. In a randomised trial of 82 patients followed for 8 to 12 years, people treated with surgery tended to have better pain and function scores, and the risk of arthritis of the subtalar joint on X-rays was 41% lower (PMID 23925738). In a randomised trial of 424 patients, some groups did better after surgery, including younger people, people with lighter workloads, people not on workers’ compensation and those in whom the joint surface was restored to its normal position (PMID 12377902).

Dr Alexey Borshch guiding foot and ankle rehabilitation with a resistance band after a fracture

If a fusion of the subtalar joint is needed later, an earlier operation can make it more successful. In a study of 69 patients who needed a subtalar fusion for arthritis, those who had their fracture fixed first had fewer wound complications and higher foot function scores (90.8 compared with 79.1) than those first treated without surgery, because fixation had restored the shape, alignment and height of the heel bone (PMID 19255213).

Minimally invasive techniques lower the risk of wound problems. In a review of 9 studies with 1,031 patients, wound complications occurred in 4.3% of people after minimally invasive fixation compared with 21.2% after open fixation (PMID 30233817). The sinus tarsi approach has been linked with fewer complications and shorter operations than the extensile lateral approach (PMID 30249288), and in a review of 21 studies with 2,086 patients both approaches restored the shape of the heel bone equally well on X-rays (PMID 38729077).

What are the risks of calcaneus fracture surgery?

Surgery does not always give a better result than treatment without an operation. In the UK Heel Fracture Trial of 151 patients, there was no difference in pain and function two years after injury between people treated with and without surgery, and complications and further operations were more common after surgery (PMID 25059747). In the trial of 424 patients, results were similar overall when the groups were not divided (PMID 12377902). The Cochrane review rated the evidence as low certainty and found little or no difference in return to work or in the need for a later subtalar fusion (PMID 37933733).

Wound healing problems and infection are the main concerns, because the skin over the outer side of the heel is thin. In a study of 490 operations with plates through the extensile lateral approach, wound complications occurred in 17.8%, and smoking, diabetes and more complex fractures were the strongest risk factors (PMID 23564422). Wound complications were 2.82 times as likely with the extensile lateral approach as with the sinus tarsi approach (PMID 38729077). In the Cochrane review, 14% of people treated with surgery had a superficial wound infection, deep infection occurred in 5.3% in one study, 3.4% needed removal of the implants, and in one study of 42 patients 2.4% needed an amputation (PMID 37933733). A long-term randomised trial also found a higher risk of complications after surgery (PMID 23925738).

A calcaneus fracture is a serious injury, and ongoing pain, stiffness of the subtalar joint and arthritis can occur after any treatment. Some people need a later fusion of the subtalar joint (subtalar arthrodesis) (PMID 19255213). Plates and screws are sometimes removed in a later operation if they cause irritation. Other possible problems include irritation of the nerve on the outer side of the foot causing numbness, a wider heel, swelling, a visible scar and the risks of the anaesthetic, which your anaesthetist will discuss with you.

Summary

Calcaneus fracture surgery aims to restore the shape of the heel bone and the surface of the subtalar joint, using plates and screws through a traditional or minimally invasive approach. Many people have less pain and better foot function, but wound problems, infection, ongoing pain, arthritis and further surgery are possible, and some fractures do as well without an operation. Surgery is usually recommended when the expected benefits for you outweigh the risks. You should discuss your injury, your scans, your general health and your goals, including your work, sport and other activities, with your fracture surgeon so that you can consider the options and the indications for treatment together.

General information only. The information on this page is general in nature and does not replace individual medical advice. All surgery carries risks, and results vary between patients. Please discuss your own circumstances with your treating practitioner.

Call usRequest appointmentAppointmentRefer patientRefer